Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
Can we have this stickied please?
http://www.muledeerworkinggroup.com/...20Fact%206.pdf
Antler restrictions are harvest restrictions that limit buck
harvest to animals that meet specific antler criteria. The
most common type of antler restriction is a point restriction.
Antler point restrictions have been used as a harvest strategy
with the hope they will increase the number of large-antlered
bucks in a mule deer population. Experience of many states
and provinces with antler point restrictions suggest this
harvest strategy has very limited potential to produce more
trophy bucks and could result in other unintended challenges.
BACKGROUND
Increasing the number of big-antlered bucks is typically the
basis for hunter demands to implement antler point restrictions.
The idea seems straightforward and promising; if we just don’t
allow hunters to harvest young bucks, they will grow older and
bigger and be available for harvest later. Most western states
and provinces have, at one point in time, employed some type
of antler point restriction attempting to increase the number of
“trophy” bucks in their herds.
THE GOOD
• Decreases hunter pressure and total buck harvest by discouraging some hunters who do not want to be
restricted to a particular antler-sized buck. This can be beneficial when harvest is heavy in relation to the
number of available bucks, but not heavy enough to warrant changing to limited quota seasons.
• In some cases, antler point restrictions have increased the proportion of bucks in the population, but this
effect may not be long-lasting.
• In remote areas with limited access, antler point restrictions have been used in combination with general
seasons to maintain hunter opportunity
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
THE BAD
• Antler point restrictions focus all the hunting pressure on the oldest age classes of bucks, gradually decrease the
average age of the buck segment of the population, and make it more difficult for bucks to reach the older age
classes due to the displaced harvest pressure.
• Antler point restrictions have been shown to reduce the number of trophy bucks over time by protecting only the
smaller-antlered young bucks.
• Antler point restrictions do not increase fawn production or population size. Even in herds with very low
buck:doe ratios (<10:100), pregnancy rates are well over 90%. Large increases in buck ratios result in relatively
few, or no, additional fawns.
THE UGLY
• Antler point restrictions dramatically reduce hunter participation, harvest success, and total harvest.
• Antler point restrictions increase the number of deer shot and illegally left in the field; this can be significant,
and has been documented in Wyoming, Colorado, Utah, Oregon, Nevada, and Montana.
• Antler point restrictions can cheapen the value of young bucks by changing the threshold for success from
“a buck” to a quest where only a big buck will do.
• Antler point restrictions may discourage hunters (especially beginning and young hunters) by increasing the
difficulty of locating and identifying legal deer.
CONCLUSIONS
After decades of use and many evaluations reporting disappointing results, most western states and provinces
have discontinued statewide antler point restrictions. The two main reasons for abandoning widespread antler
point restrictions are (1) unacceptable accidental-illegal kill, and (2) harvest mortality was increased (focused) on
the very age classes they intended to promote. Available data and experience suggest antler point restrictions result
in no long-term increase in either the proportion or number of mature bucks, or the total deer population. A few
jurisdictions still have limited areas with antler point restrictions, due to hunter preference. The use of antler point
restrictions in a combined strategy with general seasons is used in at least one case to maximize hunting opportunity.
There are additional reasons why the widespread use of antler point restrictions has not been successful. Research
has shown buck fawns born to does in poor body condition have difficulty outgrowing the effects of poor body
condition at birth, and may never reach their genetic potential for antler growth. Regulations protecting these
bucks from harvest are counterproductive to the intended benefit.
Most western states and provinces have concluded that sustainable improvements in buck:doe ratios and the number
of mature bucks can only be realized by reducing harvest through 1) a limited-quota license system that decreases
overall total buck harvest while allowing some level of doe harvest, or 2) setting a very short hunting season in early
fall when more mature bucks are less vulnerable.
It has been suggested while antler point restrictions may increase the proportion of bucks in certain populations with
low buck:doe ratios, there is no evidence they substantially increase the total number of adult (mature) bucks.
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
The results of many years of antler restrictive seasons in the peace confirm these conclusions. A classic case study
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
I believe it, but I also believe that the harvest in the kootenays at this time needs to be limited in some way, shape or form.
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
Small font sizes give me a headache. Must be getting old.
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
Ya I think it's through my thick skull now lol
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Husky7mm
I believe it, but I also believe that the harvest in the kootenays at this time needs to be limited in some way, shape or form.
Do you want more deer or do you want to limit the hunting season and harvest?
These are two very separate issues. One is about wildlife, the other is about you.
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
Long any buck bow seasons. Lots of hunting, very little mortality.
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
Quote:
Originally Posted by
HarryToolips
Ya I think it's through my thick skull now lol
Cheers, Harry! What a difference a year makes. :-D
Re: Mule Deer and Antler point restrictions
Quote:
Originally Posted by
emerson
Long any buck bow seasons. Lots of hunting, very little mortality.
Read the post above yours