wich deer is bigger

[Jeff88]

my daughter asked me to ask u guys what u think ..i say mines bigger she says hers is

http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/attach1.jpg
http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/deer1121.jpg

[Mulehahn]

hard to tell from the pic of your deer, but I gotta give it to her.

[Jeff88]

hard to tell from the pic of your deer, but I gotta give it to her.

hey ..your making my daughter gloat

[Whonnock Boy]

Based on the standard equation of inches of antler divided by years of hunting experience, your daughters deer is bigger by a country mile.

[Fido]

hers by along shot

[Jeff88]

my deer has 3 inch brows and is twice as gerthy but hers has longer tines

[REMINGTON JIM]

my deer has 3 inch brows and is twice as gerthy but hers has longer tines

Brow tines don't count on a muley but the tines on hers count as does your girth ! LOL :) RJ

[Jeff88]

heres another of jennas http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/deer50.jpg


this is my set
http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/IMG079antlers.jpg

[deer nut]

Yours looks to have better mass but hey - they're both nice and a great deer for a new hunter! Hope my daughter bags one like that someday!

[Foxton Gundogs]

hard to tell from the pic of your deer, but i gotta give it to her.

x2...........

[shadow1982]

hang up your guns jeff... there is a new top hunter in your family

[snareman1234]

Brow tines don't count on a muley but the tines on hers count as does your girth ! LOL :) RJ

B & C says they do..G1's?

[870]

Based on the standard equation of inches of antler divided by years of hunting experience, your daughters deer is bigger by a country mile.

better mass and brow tines on yours but I'm going to have to agree with Whonnock

[scoutlt1]

Where is she taking you hunting this fall? ;-)

[Jeff88]

This is Jenna, ( jeffs daughter ) .. and i know, my dads a rookie, it took him all his life to get a deer like his, and mines still bigger LOL.
-Jenna.

[springpin]

Way to take it to the old man Jenna!! Both are nice deer.

[guest]

HER'S !!

ct

[silvertipp]

heres another of jennas http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/deer50.jpg


this is my set
http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/IMG079antlers.jpg

Come on Jeff whatt kind of crap are you trying to pull
Afar away picture of hers and a nice close up of yours
id probaly pas on your deer
She wins!!!!
END OF STORY

[Tikka270]

Have any pics of them side by side? I voted for Jenna's anyways.

[Johnny G1]

Jenna, You should teach your Dad how to hunt, your deer is way bigger than that scrawny one he shot.

[bccanadian]

x2...........

x3...........

[coglark]

Gee, who voted for jeffs i wonder! lol... u go girl

[Jeff88]

http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/rack6.jpg

http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/rack22.jpg

my younger daughhttp://www.hunt101.com/data/500/rack31.jpgter jesse is holding mine

[Jeff88]

u guys got it wrong

[The Hermit]

Jenna that is a fine fine animal you got there and probably a bigger trophy than Jeff's. I wouldn't pass on your dad's either though. I'm sure he is as proud as a dad can get about now! Well done!

[Matty_ola]

For fear of being punched in the face or shot from 635 yards away I'm going to have to vote for Jeff on this one.... ;)

[Jeff88]

.
For fear of being punched in the face or shot from 635 yards away I'm going to have to vote for Jeff on this one.... ;)

640....... get it right eh

[hillclimber]

jenna's is taller but just a tad smaller in width and jeff's has more mass. i think jeff's is bigger

[pnbrock]

Girls rule boys drule. You got him girl!!

[Jeff88]

Girls rule boys drule. You got him girl!!

boy ..al the positve comments has jenna super proud now ..and boy is she razzen me ....thanks guys ...just kidden ...positive comments have made her really wanting to get back out there

[nolimits]

It looks so far like only 7 guys are on Jeffs payroll ;) . Way to go Jenna!!! How I love those little family challenges.

[scoutlt1]

It looks so far like only 7 guys are on Jeffs payroll ;) . Way to go Jenna!!! How I love those little family challenges.

6 actually...I doubt if Jeff is paying himself! ;-)

[Jeff88]

6 actually...I doubt if Jeff is paying himself! ;-)

oh man ...u guys have no idea how much she is gloating...shes going .....in your face dad...... whos the rookie now dad.... you wanna come hunting,,follow me...

[nolimits]

6 actually...I doubt if Jeff is paying himself! ;-)

LOL You got that right :mrgreen:

[Lillypuff]

Great way to spend family time good on both of you. A little family competive wager coming soon? Jenna does some extra chores if dads buck is bigger next year and dad has too splurge for some new hunting related articles if Jenna's is bigger? Good on you guys nice too see

[scoutlt1]

oh man ...u guys have no idea how much she is gloating...shes going .....in your face dad...... whos the rookie now dad.... you wanna come hunting,,follow me...


Thanks for starting the thread Jeff! Good fun! :-) And congrats to your daughter for bagging the bigger buck! ;-)

[dino]

your gay ! and not the happy gay

[Jeff88]

your gay ! and not the happy gay


i said PARDON....and the champ looses it

[Mulehahn]

your gay ! and not the happy gay

Huh, the fact that he has a daughter who can out hunt him proves he is not gay. Or am I missing something. Where did this comment even come from. Sorry Jeff don't mean to hijack the thread its just comments like this is a great thread really piss me off.

[scoutlt1]

your gay ! and not the happy gay

I don't get it... :-s who's gay and why? lol

[Jeff88]

I don't get it... :-s who's gay and why? lol


just an asswipe trying to push my buttons ...no worries ill clean the floor with em later in the season up in his stompin grounds

[nolimits]

just an asswipe trying to push my buttons ...no worries ill clean the floor with em later in the season up in his stompin grounds

Too bad there are asswipes like this, trying to ruin such a nice family thread.

[scoutlt1]

just an asswipe trying to push my buttons ...no worries ill clean the floor with em later in the season up in his stompin grounds


Too bad huh? Like I said, fun thread Jeff!
And good on ya for taking your kids hunting and fishing. I wish more parents would do the same! It's the best thing a father or mother can do with their children. The world would be a much better place if it happened more often.

[Jeff88]

Too bad huh? Like I said, fun thread Jeff!
And good on ya for taking your kids hunting and fishing. I wish more parents would do the same! It's the best thing a father or mother can do with their children. The world would be a much better place if it happened more often.\

totally agree ...taking the kids out there is just as satasfying for me as for them if they bag something. jenna was jumping three feet in the air after i took the gun outa her hands and said u got it..it dropped so fast that she didnt see it thru the scope

[troutseeker]

I say hers, just as I would say my daughter's, even if it was not!

[Jeff88]

heres one more i just found

http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/IMG036jennas.jpg

[nolimits]

heres one more i just found

http://www.hunt101.com/data/500/IMG036jennas.jpg


....and with this smile you voted for yourself Jeff?? Shame on ya!! :)

[Jeff88]

....and with this smile you voted for yourself Jeff?? Shame on ya!! :)

haha ...i had to ...i new she would have the upper hand on me ...

[Mulehahn]

Love the pic. She must be smiling just as big now that we have confirmed her suspiscions that her deer is bigger. Hope you both top them this year. Way to go Jeff.

[Moose Guide]

Put a tape on them, then the argument will be over!

[scottwh]

Both nice deer Jeff and Jenna! My daughter who is also Jenna, said your deer is a wee bit bigger, but Jenna's is a whole lot BETTER :)

[hunter1947]

I say the old mans deer is bigger..

[dino]

Huh, the fact that he has a daughter who can out hunt him proves he is not gay. Or am I missing something. Where did this comment even come from. Sorry Jeff don't mean to hijack the thread its just comments like this is a great thread really piss me off.

Your missing something.

[coach]

Does it really matter, Jeff? I mean, now that Jenna has learned to hunt, you won't even be in the competition anymore. Consider this little battle the beginning of the end. I expect every year, from now on, she'll take a bigger one than you.

Here's to you, Jenna, for educating the old man again this coming September. :-D

[dino]

just an asswipe trying to push my buttons ...no worries ill clean the floor with em later in the season up in his stompin grounds

Ive had guys twice your size beat me up. What are you gonna do?LOL.




Call me when your gonna go get your cam and if you wanna stretch the legs of your mag I will take to my range.

[Jeff88]

Does it really matter, Jeff? I mean, now that Jenna has learned to hunt, you won't even be in the competition anymore. Consider this little battle the beginning of the end. I expect every year, from now on, she'll take a bigger one than you.

Here's to you, Jenna, for educating the old man again this coming September. :-D

nothing wrong with some good ole compition..kids these days dont have 1st ,2nd ,3rd.place in there track meets or fun days ...they all just get participation ribbons ...i totally disagree with this system ..if u try hard and win ,u should be rewarded ..if your lazy and dont even try and get the same reward as the kid who works his ,her ass of ...that is wrong

[Jeff88]

Ive had guys twice your size beat me up. What are you gonna do?LOL.




Call me when your gonna go get your cam and if you wanna stretch the legs of your mag I will take to my range.

sounds good dino ...i just put a new scope on ,so i need to start from scratch

[coach]

nothing wrong with some good ole compition..kids these days dont have 1st ,2nd ,3rd.place in there track meets or fun days ...they all just get participation ribbons ...i totally disagree with this system ..if u try hard and win ,u should be rewarded ..if your lazy and dont even try and get the same reward as the kid who works his ,her ass of ...that is wrong

I agree with you there, Jeff! (Even if your punctuation, spelling and spacing is hard to follow.:-D)

[Jeff88]

I agree with you there, Jeff! (Even if your punctuation, spelling and spacing is hard to follow.:-D)


comeon coach it aint really that bad ...

[coach]

Ha ha! You're right, Jeff. At least I can understand it. Back to the important subject, Jenna's is a great buck!

[dogger]

Your the winner Jeff. You get to go hunting with your kid!!

[Jeff88]

Your the winner Jeff. You get to go hunting with your kid!!

so true my friend .....

[Jeff88]

just bringing this thread back up so jenna can get more votes ....on her request.....

[Caveman]

You have to total the inches under the B&C scoring system and divide by the hunters weight to do this fairly, and I believe the net inches/lbs score, the title goes to your daughter Jeff!

Both respectable deer though. Never the less she has years to better this one, and I'm sure she will

[Jeff88]

You have to total the inches under the B&C scoring system and divide by the hunters weight to do this fairly, and I believe the net inches/lbs score, the title goes to your daughter Jeff!

Both respectable deer though. Never the less she has years to better this one, and I'm sure she will

it took me 20 flippen years to get that deer and she gets hers the first 5 mins into her very first hunt ....hope thats a sighn of things to come ...shes going to get the moose draw this year ....we hope ...my 16 year old son got it last year and he got a nice little bull ...i woulda showed some pics but my bloody phone somehow erased all my pics from that trip...

[bccanadian]

Congratulations Jenna and good for you Jeff for encouraging a new hunter.

Jenna, it didn't take you long to show your dad what a big set of antlers really looks like...:-D

[Jeff88]

well i just scored them to the best of my ability on the boon and crocket website...mine scored 142 3/8 ...jennas scored 140 1/8...her tines are longer ,mine are alot thicker...i gotta give it to her ,it took me 25 years to get that buck ,it took her 25 minutes on opening morning...so she wins ..hands down

[Jeff88]

and that score is without measuring the brows ..the boon and crocket table didnt have brows as an option to punch in the measurments of them