Best tasting meat

[pete_k]

Just getting opinions via poll on what others consider best tasting meat of the following animals.

[bsa30-06]

Had some elk a few years back was by far the best game meat i had.

[eastkoot]

Where's the beef???

[tomahawk]

Your poll doesn't include the best from BC and that's Bison.

[Gateholio]

I've eaten lots of bison, but mostly it's been from SSSSters dad's ranch. :mrgreen:

I've never had a bison tag,:???:

Of your choices, I'd take a youngish moose for best overall eating.

[ElkMasterC]

Blacktail, and looking forward to some Roosevelt meat.
Something about that rainforest purple fine grained chop from heaven.
I prefer it to all others now.

[Salty]

Something about that rainforest purple fine grained chop from heaven.
I prefer it to all others now.

That right there is the deal.

[mark]

I've eaten lots of bison, but mostly it's been from SSSSters dad's ranch. :mrgreen:

I've never had a bison tag,:???:

Of your choices, I'd take a youngish moose for best overall eating.

Couldnt agree more, young moose is the best by far! Way better than bison or elk!

[Steeleco]

I'm not seeing Bear either? Nobody ever said I was normal!!! But to pick from the list, Moose, and young if possible.

[porcupine]

Fillet of Fallow Deer loin from Sidney Island. It's like the best veal that you ever had only sooo much better. My brother once came out east for a visit and he wanted to have the deer that his son raved about. I served this to him and he was, as the British say, gob struck.
________
volcano vaporizers (http://www.vaporshop.com/volcano-vaporizer.html)

[Big7]

Moose, bison, whitetail deer, mule deer, elk, grouse, bear, wild rabbit, squirrel....in that order I guess!

[log_roller]

Just getting opinions via poll on what others consider best tasting meat of the following animals.

Id have to say it will all make you shit :mrgreen:

[Sitkaspruce]

Blacktail, and looking forward to some Roosevelt meat.
Something about that rainforest purple fine grained chop from heaven.
I prefer it to all others now.

Yup...The island meat is pretty good.

The best tasting meat by far is Mountain Sheep, but since you do not have it as a choice, then a young bull moose is a close second.

My rosie from a couple years ago was pretty good as well, much better than any MT Rocky elk I have had.

Worst was my biggest mulie, could smell him from 50' away and still smell him when ever we opened up a package of meat. The only animal I fed to the bears.......the wife simple refused to cook or eat it, and I was right behind her.

Cheers

SS

[silvertipp]

nice early stone sheep

[ElkMasterC]

I want opinions on sheep and goat, as I have the distinct misfortune of never tasting either.

Tell me your tales of glee or woe!

[.308win]

Tried all on the list, and IMO the whitetail is by far the best!!........Next to the Woodland Caribou from back home of corse!!:mrgreen:

Perry

[M@B]

QCI BT's case closed!! :)

[pete_k]

I would have posted bear, bison, sheep and goat (and squirrel for Big7) but the polling feature only lets you do 4 choices.

Good to hear all your opinions. Looks like the young bull moose have it by a nose on the elk.

I'll be putting alot of energy into a spike fork next year.

Keep'em coming!!

[JCVD]

Elk by far, Then non predator habitat raised Blacktail or antelope, then moose, whitetail,and finally muley.

[Marcus.wheeler]

Buffalo burgers and Elk steaks are amazing.... plus bear peporoni !

[compton]

Right now I have a huge freezer full of elk, moose, whitetail, mulie, goat, black bear and fallow deer. And the fallow deer is consistently the best with elk a close second.

[TDoyle]

Id have to say it will all make you shit :mrgreen:

Yup, eating will do that to ya!

[The Hermit]

I actually like Cougar best but voted moose but its really a toss up between moose and elk for me. I love it all though!!!

[Barracuda]

If its just dear I like whitetail and BlackTail .

Moose is too much like a cow .

I also like sheep and goat but it really depends on how drunk i am :mrgreen:

[todbartell]

hands down, elk. The meat off my bull this year is unreal

[Wild Images]

Stone sheep up on the hill after a great hunt
You can't buy a meal like that :-D

[sawmill]

Ate them all except cat.A good young moose,Whities for sure,a nice Mulie or a young Elk.The only BT I shot must have been eating seaweed off the beach in the Queen Charlottes,tasted like a fishes ass.Ate a hunting partner once,well not all of him,he was better than starving to death,not too bad if a guy had some Fava beans.RIP Randy.:mrgreen:

[Phil]

It's hard to beat a tender slab of bullwinkle. I sure do like mule deer chops though.

[dave_83golf]

I was on a hunt with my fiancee this year who had a moose tag, and she knocked down a 2nd year moose..... By far the best meat ive ever had. Cutting t-bones with a fork....yummmm

[sheep.elk.moose fanatic]

Stone Sheep!!!!!i Need To Say No More!!!

[catparts]

I preffer elk any age its good stuff,, but i tried squirrel once and everyone thought i was nuts!

[KB90]

I would have posted bear, bison, sheep and goat (and squirrel for Big7) but the polling feature only lets you do 4 choices.

Good to hear all your opinions. Looks like the young bull moose have it by a nose on the elk.

I'll be putting alot of energy into a spike fork next year.

Keep'em coming!!

Moose meat is by far my favorite. Elk is a close second.

I once had a lama roast and that was pretty good:tongue:

For the future you can do more than 4 poll choices :) It's an option you can choose when you are making it.

[bforce750]

The best meat by far was a late season caribou,the dogs loved it.

[moosinaround]

Elk and a young bull moose are very close to the best! I had a buffalo ribeye last night that was pretty freakin good though!! Moosin

[riflebuilder]

Axis deer is by far the best game meat I have ever tasted. I do like Elk and Moose too. A early season mulie is good BTare good, damn now I am hungry got to go cook something

[bowhunterbruce]

although the choice were limited i voted moose from your selection ,however had there have been more choices i would put mtn goat 1st,for flavor and tenderness,i have never had a bad tasting cut of moose be he old or young.eliminating all the animals fat in ungulates like deer,moose,elk and ensuring there is no bone either will take out any wild taste in the meat.so it all is very yummy.
bruce

[pete_k]

Looks like the ELK and Moose are tied.
I've read posts on here where some guys consider 6 point Elk as un-eatable. I was thinking Moose would have got more votes than Elk.

[Stillhunting]

Young moose by a mile. Then whitey, muley, and elk in that order. I've never tasted a young elk though so it could move up a spot or two, if I should have the opportunity to sample it.

[Beaverhunter]

I think a young bull moose would have to be my favorite.

[pappy]

the best I've had was couger steak then moose steak all on the b.b.q. then whitetail.

[1/2 slam]

nice early stone sheep

Without a doubt!

[ElkMasterC]

Can't believe cougar and beaver aren't on the list.

You should do another pole. (sic)

[capt.T]

out of the deer. got all three this year and had "sample" dinner the other night. cooked all three back steaks. rated as follows white tail, black tail, mule deer. but, young moose still the best.

[pete_k]

bump please

[one-shot-wonder]

Bighorn sheep is my favourite, but I voted moose.....hard to beat an immature bull!

[kebes]

I haven't had it but my dad and grandpa always say sheep is the best (they always shot stones). Elk's the best I've had.

[WaterSkeeter]

I love my moose

[betteroffishing]

had the good fortune to try elk meat last summer , now im ruined .

[pete_k]

bump please

[Woody]

calf moose mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

[hunterofthedeer]

i abosolutly love moose then elk and then probably grouse

[Maverick7]

elk makes an amazing table fair. but many people would agree texada BT are equally amazing.

[Lance Barkman]

My September Mulie tastes just as good as my elk!

[Moose72]

September muley is awsome. Then a young moose. Bin tryin my cali sheep from this year and i can't complain about that either.

[Islandeer]

Young whities are hard to beat!! And for pep you can't beat a good Vancouver Island berry bear taken in late Sept.

island cow elk likely top's my list though.

damn I like it all!!!! :-?

[pete_k]

I want to revive this thread again.
Elk have it, but I think it should be Moose.

My whitetail this year is absolutely fine. The least gamey deer I have
ever eaten. I eat my whitetail deersteaks rare.
Even the wife eats them medium rare and normaly they would have to be cooked through.

(Kind of like Bush vs. Gore 2000. Keep counting till you win)

[pescado]

Elk, Whitetail, Moose than Blacktails for me. The whitey's suprise me.

[wolverine]

I shall be dining on medium rare Elk this evening.... nothing finer in my opinion.

[1/2 slam]

I've eaten them all. Not one compares to Stone Sheep.

[115 or bust]

I'm not sure that there are enough options on there, for instance september blacktail would be much better than november whitetail. When I was a kid my favorite was mountain goat, you need to add, bear, MT goat, sheep, blacktail, early season that is, white tails and mulies off grain feilds are a different world from mountain deer again. etc lol we could have a 1 page survey for this one.

[wrenchpuller]

I thought elk was tops but in all honesty, I tasted berry fed grizzly this year and I was really impressed.

[Fraink]

Ate them all except cat.A good young moose,Whities for sure,a nice Mulie or a young Elk.The only BT I shot must have been eating seaweed off the beach in the Queen Charlottes,tasted like a fishes ass.Ate a hunting partner once,well not all of him,he was better than starving to death,not too bad if a guy had some Fava beans.RIP Randy.:mrgreen:

Never had a hunting partner I would eat !!

[HailCall]

Elk is my favorite followed by quail. Unfortunately for me I have never shot an elk so I am stuck begging from buddies who get lucky enough to draw a Ne tag (really tough). Cornfed whitetail ranks up there the Mulies I have eaten taste like sage.

[tikybear]

For me calf moose is the very best eating ever

[835]

man that was hard!
moose though i love it

[pete_k]

Looks like the Elk have it. I would have guessed moose as I've not heard many good things about stinky old 6 point bull Elk.

[Barracuda]

moose is boreing , gimme something with real flavour like vancouver island marmont served with a side of spotted owl:mrgreen:

I actually prefer deer to moose .

[Ubertuber]

Elk is nice, but an immature moose gets my nod for best tasting on your list.