PDA

View Full Version : Heartbreaker in region 8 - bowhunting whitetail



KootenayKiller
01-26-2024, 03:19 PM
I had a hunt this fall that I thought worth sharing. I am not proud of it, the end result was every hunter's worst nightmare - a wounded animal, most likely mortal, and no retrieval. I think it is worth sharing our failures, as well as our success, and I am curious for other people's thoughts/perspectives.

It was December 16th, and I had just returned from a 7-week long trip overseas. Having missed much of the fall hunting season, I was eager to get out and enjoy the crisp Kootenay countryside. I made a 4 hour drive to the Grand Forks area in region 8, where I planned to hunt. My goal was to test the waters on my new winter camping gear, be outside and re-calibrate to this side of the planet, and maybe get lucky. I like exploring new areas, hiking long distances, and was excited to take it all in. I was driving towards some crown land I had hunted the year prior, but it was getting dark and so I decided to pitch my tent 45 minutes from my destination since I happened to be next to crown land and didn't want to pitch my tent in the dark. I notice a lot of fresh deer tracks, so I decide to sit the morning out in that location. I angle my tent door towards the game trail, and get setup before bed. I wake up 30 minutes before sunrise, and get situated. After about an hour, I hear crashing in the forest behind me. All of a sudden a couple of white-tail does run out and one stops, presenting me with a perfect broadside shot at 40 yards. I line up for the vitals, aiming for an exit wound slightly behind the front shoulder. I shoot and believe it was on target, but something feels wrong and I am immediately worried. I see the deer kick like they do when they are hit good, and then run off, but it still just felt wrong for some reason. I waited 5 minutes, then quietly left the area and hiked back to my car to give the animal time to expire, if needed. So I made breakfast and started preparing for the retrieval.

After about 45 minutes, I return and walk up to the point of impact. I find my bloody arrow, and large amounts of blood with a fairly thick trail. I felt relief and excitement. Unfortunately, as I start tracking it, I realize looking at the iHunter app on my phone that the deer wandered into private land. So, once I figure out the general direction it went in, I knocked on some doors to ask for permission to keep tracking it. One of the fine gentlemen that gave me permission is a fellow hunter, and decided to come help me with the recovery. For this I was very grateful s he knew the locals and lay of the land. After tracking the blood trail for about a kilometer and few hundred meters of altitude gain, I figure I must not have hit the vitals like I thought. Despite the large pools of blood, I decide to back off and give the doe more time to pass without spooking it. So, my new friend kindly invites me to his home for coffee and bear sausage. We enjoy this, and then return to pick up on where we left off after a couple of hours. Long story short is that we followed the blood trail until sunset, and walked back in the dark. We covered close to 20km, and about 700m of elevation gain. We were really impressed by how far this deer was able to move, given the steady stream of blood and occasional patches of big pools of blood. My new friend generously offered me to stay in a heated trailer of his overnight which I gladly accepted. That night I went to bed hopeful that the cold night would sap the deer of any energy it may have had left, but I had bad feeling that it was not dead. I picked the trail back up in the morning, and followed it to an area where the deer had bedded down for the night. Each spot it lay in was evident by large pools of blood, which were obviously located on the front half of its chest area as expected. Despite searching all day and covering another 15km, I knew it was all over. Snow was coming the next morning to bury the tracks, and my knees were giving out. By the time I got back to the car, I was having difficulty walking and knew that I wouldn't be capable of searching anymore even if the snow were to hold off. I ran the scenario through my head a thousand times, not sure what I should have done better, on the drive home.

This video shows the blood trail, after about 10-15km from shooting location: https://imgur.com/XfKRfYi

https://i.imgur.com/LITw5Y6h.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/vaR7Kl0h.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/KX0mlBuh.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/re4DHZth.jpg

I know I took a good shot. I was 40 yards out with the deer standing still and broadside. I have practiced shooting this distance countless times with consistently good accuracy. I took my time and am sure the arrow hit where I aimed. I was confused, though, because I didn't have meat in my vehicle. Did the deer flinch at the last moment? Did the arrow deflect off a branch? It didn't make sense to me, because I saw the arrow go through this animal broadside in the optimal location. Well, I accepted that I will never know what went wrong, and consoled myself only with knowing that I gave retrieval my best effort. Nonetheless I am gutted.

Two weeks go by, and I get a text message from my newfound friend saying that my deer may still be alive. He then sends me a picture showing a doe on his property with a recent wound exactly where the exit wound would have been on my deer. I've uploaded this photo for all to see. The entry would would have been coming from slightly forward of this on the other side, but almost running straight through. Is this really possible, with that shot location for the deer to still be alive and healthy two weeks later? The evidence points towards this being the case but it just seems hard to believe. This is the only photo he was able to take, but he told me that it appeared to have been a good shot, and that the deer seemed in good health.

I certainly have gained a new respect for how tough these animals are. I lost a deer that weekend, but made a new friend and hunting partner.

https://i.imgur.com/lTJNT44.jpg

Hunter gatherer
01-26-2024, 04:44 PM
Thanks for sharing your story, lots of blood should have led to a dead deer. I have to ask, what kind of broadhead were you using? Just curious

KootenayKiller
01-26-2024, 04:55 PM
CenterPoint DEADPOINT™ Broadheads, shot with Centerpoint Amped 425 crossbow

lovemywinchester
01-26-2024, 05:36 PM
It happens...My buddy shot a deer this fall near dusk, about 120 yds, with a rest on the ground. Fell down but got up and took off. Same situation but with little snow. Looked for two days, Never found it. Tough buggers....Figures he hit it low in the brisket.

scttlp86
01-26-2024, 05:41 PM
My first guess would be the broadhead didnt open properly. Maybe it opened on the offside hide.

srupp
01-26-2024, 05:43 PM
hmmm you made an exemplary effort on retrieval...it would be nice if the animal was indeed alive...sure a lot of blood to be putting on those distances...

appreciate the read.
cheers
Steven

KootenayKiller
01-26-2024, 06:03 PM
My first guess would be the broadhead didn't open properly. Maybe it opened on the offside hide.

I can only hope that is the case, and that the arrow didn't hit both lungs so that she was able to recover. My other thought is that maybe the arrow struck during an exhale contributing to one or both lungs not being hit? I was truly astounded by the amount of blood loss that occurred, over such long distances, and through mostly uphill terrain no less. It seemed not possible! I was even more surprised to receive a picture of what appears to be that same deer a full two weeks later, I was certain she would have been cougar feed by then.

One thing I found very interesting was that she did many loops, where she doubled back onto her original track, making figure-8s if that makes sense. This made it difficult to track even with a consistent blood trail. My guess is that this must be a natural response to confuse any predators that might be trying to track her.

blaine
01-26-2024, 08:53 PM
With all that blood I don't think it will take the predators too long to find the doe.

jlirot
01-26-2024, 09:18 PM
Wow. Great story. Bummer but well done.

I had a rough one this fall too. Shot a doe. I have no idea how I missed so badly - lots of ideas but no proof and it doesn't make any difference because the mistake is mine regardless. It was a crummy shot. I got mine but it wasn't one and done like we all want it to be.

You did everything right. Still sucks.

Treed
01-27-2024, 12:32 AM
Zombie deer! Jokes aside - you did everything right and your commitment to tracking her and trying to retrieve her is commendable. My first whitetail with a bow was a little buck with three legs. The back left leg was 4 inches too short but healed over. They are very tough. Bad stuff happens occasionally hunting. All we can do is make sure we are proficient with our weapons and do what you did when things go astray.

Redthies
01-27-2024, 05:43 AM
Well, I would try to sleep better knowing it looks like she recovered. I helped a neighbor look for a deer that bolted at last light the next morning, and despite tracking and finding a ton of blood, we never found his deer. We did find another deer with two G bears eating it though. I know my neighbor was gutted by not finding his buck, but I told him this “yes, it sucks to lose the animal, but if the wolves etc find it, they will eat it, and another deer will not be hunted down by them that day”. It’s a different way to look at it, but every meal the preds get of a wounded or sick deer, is one less healthy deer that might make a mistake that day being eaten.

I’ve only taken one whitetail with a bow, and I will stick to rifle shots if at all possible. They can go wrong too, but I think it’s less likely if you do your part correctly.


What watershed / FSR were you hunting? I live in the GF area.

KootenayKiller
01-27-2024, 08:09 AM
No FSR or watershed, it was just a turnoff from Granby road onto an unusable logging road in crown land, about 20 mins north of GF. I hiked in a ways from there.

I'm not sure if mechanical broadhead was a contributing factor, but I think I'll be using fixed broadheads in the future.

HarryToolips
01-27-2024, 11:17 AM
Sounds like you did everything you could man, and you showed persistence on the attempted retrieval... they are very tough animals, I lost a mule deer buck once after a shot with a bow that I know lived..

Walking Buffalo
01-28-2024, 08:22 AM
I want to hear more about how you were able to track this doe for 20 km in one afternoon and 15 km the next day.

Very impressive, almost unbelievable.

KootenayKiller
01-28-2024, 10:33 AM
I want to hear more about how you were able to track this doe for 20 km in one afternoon and 15 km the next day.

Very impressive, almost unbelievable.

There were consistent drops of blood over this distance, interspersed with pools of blood every 100 feet or so. We couldn't believe it either... How many liters of blood can a deer lose? A lot apparently. This was not linear distance, but the distance that my GPS tracking app recorded as we meandered.

Pretty normal distances for me... I am young and hike a lot lol

Woodchuck Dan
01-30-2024, 07:24 PM
I appreciate the willingness to share a difficult experience as well as being an example of the efforts that can be gone to to retrieve an animal. Hope this experience is sitting as right as it can with you, sounds like you did everything you could.