PDA

View Full Version : This should help....



gcreek
12-29-2018, 09:06 AM
the cause for a predator cull....


https://www.summerlandreview.com/news/wolf-cull-could-have-repercussions-in-the-okanagan/

Scotty76
12-29-2018, 10:02 AM
Is the bio, Adam Ford, saying that because wolves are being culled in different areas of B.C. that is why they are showing up in the Okanagan..? That’s what I got out of it. Or is this just a media spin looking for attention. I was under the impression that Adam Ford was a good bio. Any have any insight to this?

358mag
12-29-2018, 12:39 PM
Is the bio, Adam Ford, saying that because wolves are being culled in different areas of B.C. that is why they are showing up in the Okanagan..? That’s what I got out of it. Or is this just a media spin looking for attention. I was under the impression that Adam Ford was a good bio. Any have any insight to this?
Or maybe the reason there showing up in the Okanagan is because they have clean out all the ungulates in there "traditional " territory and looking for some new customers .

northof49
12-29-2018, 12:58 PM
^^^^this exactly. Have been spreading south in search of food. Predators go where the food is. Not very complicated. All about survival as with ALL wild animals. They don’t waste energy unless necessary. Wolves are not into sight seeing or wine tasting. They go where the food is.

PYGuy
12-29-2018, 12:59 PM
Not sure why “Good Science” can’t be carried out on wolf populations just because they are a polarizing topic. Unless humans on either side won’t let the science be carried out? The data from scientific experiments, set up properly, is also not the problem. The problem occurs when the data is interpreted And then spun to favor their position be it pro or con.

Piperdown
12-29-2018, 01:12 PM
Whoa hold on there folks lets not get ahead of ourselves, we won't know what is right until the cut and paste queen and her little side kick pemby tell us how it is

panhead
12-29-2018, 03:21 PM
Snowwolves is my bet ... heading south for the winter.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If it has tires, tracks, or tits ... sooner or later you are going to have trouble with it.

Bugle M In
12-29-2018, 03:43 PM
I saw a radio collared study of one wolf.
He travelled from basically the BC/Alberta Border around Banff/Jasper (if I recall right) and ended up around either Kootenay Lake or was it the Arrow Lakes??, but had travelled some 400 kms in a week or so.
Regardless, the wolves are moving great distances, not just a circular hunting ground over a few watersheds like in the past.
Don't know if it has much to do with culling in some areas, imo.
Personally, I think they have just bred so much now that they have to find new territories.
And are on the move looking for new hunting grounds because of killing off their previous areas.
Just my opinion.
Maybe it's a combination of both???

Jordan f.
12-29-2018, 03:45 PM
Not sure why “Good Science” can’t be carried out on wolf populations just because they are a polarizing topic. Unless humans on either side won’t let the science be carried out? The data from scientific experiments, set up properly, is also not the problem. The problem occurs when the data is interpreted And then spun to favor their position be it pro or con.

Probably has to due with lack of funding/support. Wolves are basically political suicide. Most hunters will discard any science that doesn't support shooting them, most antis will discard any science that supports shooting them. No matter what. You are getting a tsunami of complaints. Most have already chosen which side of the fence they are on... science is irrelevant at this point.

gcreek
12-29-2018, 04:24 PM
Probably has to due with lack of funding/support. Wolves are basically political suicide. Most hunters will discard any science that doesn't support shooting them, most antis will discard any science that supports shooting them. No matter what. You are getting a tsunami of complaints. Most have already chosen which side of the fence they are on... science is irrelevant at this point.

I believe you are very correct on this viewpoint. All at the cost of prey populations plummeting.

There seems to be no end of funding to study wolves and bears for that matter. Collaring, counting turds and tracks, analyzing what the turds were made from, the list goes on and never ends.

The funding seems to dry up when it is time to cull a few.

Most here know my opinion of My Goatguy so I won’t go into that. It is interesting where his name pops up and on what topics he gives support to.

horshur
12-29-2018, 04:51 PM
I saw a radio collared study of one wolf.
He travelled from basically the BC/Alberta Border around Banff/Jasper (if I recall right) and ended up around either Kootenay Lake or was it the Arrow Lakes??, but had travelled some 400 kms in a week or so.
Regardless, the wolves are moving great distances, not just a circular hunting ground over a few watersheds like in the past.
Don't know if it has much to do with culling in some areas, imo.
Personally, I think they have just bred so much now that they have to find new territories.
And are on the move looking for new hunting grounds because of killing off their previous areas.
Just my opinion.
Maybe it's a combination of both???
In the past..like when they didn’t have gps collars and researchers had no clue but took a guess anyway.FFS

Bugle M In
12-29-2018, 04:59 PM
Regardless of what was said, what info was put forth, be it from studies or speculation.
think "everyone" agrees, wolves are in more areas of BC now, in areas they have either never been before or haven't been
for many many years.
Either way, "there back"!, and it has to be dealt with.
Don't hate them, just don't need that many of them, imo.
Big Cats too...

horshur
12-29-2018, 06:28 PM
Dispel the notion that any of the foundational wolf science is valid. It has its roots in a penned pack in Germany.
Keep going back to how it was...it has never been “was”when they studied them. They are only now getting a taste of why are ancestors extirpated them...science is supposed to be free of sentiment but just read the article.

gcreek
12-29-2018, 06:48 PM
Dispel the notion that any of the foundational wolf science is valid. It has its roots in a penned pack in Germany.
Keep going back to how it was...it has never been “was”when they studied them. They are only now getting a taste of why are ancestors extirpated them...science is supposed to be free of sentiment but just read the article.


Bingo!!!!!!

horshur
12-29-2018, 06:53 PM
https://www.mawer.com/the-art-of-boring/blog/the-myth-of-the-alpha-wolf

stinkyduck
12-29-2018, 07:01 PM
Whoa hold on there folks lets not get ahead of ourselves, we won't know what is right until the cut and paste queen and her little side kick pemby tell us how it is
Bahahah........................................... .....................................I'm waiting also!!

Bugle M In
12-29-2018, 07:39 PM
That's why I mentioned the study.
Just one male wolf leaving the "family pack" to start a new family/pack I suppose elsewhere.
Never was it mentioned to be an "Alpha".

HighCountryBC
12-29-2018, 08:42 PM
I believe you are very correct on this viewpoint. All at the cost of prey populations plummeting.

There seems to be no end of funding to study wolves and bears for that matter. Collaring, counting turds and tracks, analyzing what the turds were made from, the list goes on and never ends.

The funding seems to dry up when it is time to cull a few.

Most here know my opinion of My Goatguy so I won’t go into that. It is interesting where his name pops up and on what topics he gives support to.

Just a guy who is passionate about wildlife and hunting in this great province. Has done more for both resident hunters and wildlife than probably 99.9% of folks out there. If we had a thousand GoatGuy's this province would be much better off.

gcreek
12-29-2018, 09:24 PM
Just a guy who is passionate about wildlife and hunting in this great province. Has done more for both resident hunters and wildlife than probably 99.9% of folks out there. If we had a thousand GoatGuy's this province would be much better off.



Thanks for the giggle.

Wild one
12-29-2018, 09:41 PM
Just a guy who is passionate about wildlife and hunting in this great province. Has done more for both resident hunters and wildlife than probably 99.9% of folks out there. If we had a thousand GoatGuy's this province would be much better off.

Not everyone feels the same way but you are welcome to your opinion

Ohwildwon
12-29-2018, 10:02 PM
Hmm, lots of looky loo's speaking up, on the topic...;)