Try your hand and score this buck

[leadpillproductions]

http://i617.photobucket.com/albums/tt260/leadpillproductions/deer2013033.jpg
http://i617.photobucket.com/albums/tt260/leadpillproductions/deer2013029.jpg

[Darksith]

135, but I am clueless

[300H&H]

135, but I am clueless

I don't think your that far off.
On the left antler it looks like the G2 & G3 come off the same base point so this buck is a 4X3 with a extra point.
The mass is not super but nice, inside spread is about 22".
With that said, gross score 144" and net 130".

What ever the score is, it is still a nice buck with super brows.

[huntinnut]

I'd say 136 4/8 gross. Crazy browtines.

[leadpillproductions]

4x4 main beams 21 inches just a few hints

[dellis]

I think he'll gross closer to 150.......who cares about net. But I am no expert.......fun guessing game though:mrgreen:
Darcy

[Ddog]

140-145ish..great buck

[greenhorn]

Score = awesome!!!

[Rackem]

What a HUGE body buck...

[chilcotin hillbilly]

I would think you would be surprised, I am thinking 160 ish

[Stone Sheep Steve]

145-150 gross??

[Trapper]

nice buck 130 net

[d6dan]

Good one Colin. I'll guess 142

[MacMtnHunter]

143-147... nice looking buck none the less

[BCrams]

4x4 with 21 mains but big guards to offset some shorter points on a 5x5 I'd go with 152" gross

[hare_assassin]

I'm confused. I see a 3x3 with big brow tines.

Can someone explain why brow tines count in some cases and not in others?

[knighthunter]

140-145ish..great buck

seems about right to me

[BiG Boar]

144 4/8 gross.
Nice buck. Who shot it?

[leadpillproductions]

Some good guessing . I actually thought it was going to break 150 but gross 148 5/8

[MacMtnHunter]

Some good guessing . I actually thought it was going to break 150 but gross 148 5/8

Not enough length on all of the tines to go that high... awesome buck though, I'd shoot him all day :)

[ElliotMoose]

I'm confused. I see a 3x3 with big brow tines.

Can someone explain why brow tines count in some cases and not in others?

With Whitetails, you count the brow tine as a point. With a Mulie you do not

[hare_assassin]

With Whitetails, you count the brow tine as a point. With a Mulie you do not

I noob it was something simple like this.

Thank you.

[yama49]

With Whitetails, you count the brow tine as a point. With a Mulie you do not

I agree with you, but it still a 3x3, main beam doesn't count as a point in b&c scoring, the main beam is the main beam. (main beam,G1 G2 G3)

[yama49]

Awesome deer congrats

[markt308]

gross 143 is my guess

[Mikey Rafiki]

I agree with you, but it still a 3x3, main beam doesn't count as a point in b&c scoring, the main beam is the main beam. (main beam,G1 G2 G3)

But you are wrong. From the B&C website:

To be counted a point, the projection must be at least one inch long, with the length exceeding width at one inch or more of length. All points measured from tip of point to nearest edge of beam as illustrated in Figure A. Beam tip is counted as a point, but not measured as a point.

http://www.boone-crockett.org/bgRecords/bc_scoring_typwhitetail.asp?area=bgRecords&type=Typical+Whitetail+Deer

[kennyj]

Great buck, very nice brows. 136'' net score. My guess.
kenny

[Mikey Rafiki]

I was gonna guess 147 gross.

Nets are for butterflies, etc, etc, etc...

[Rich_D]

I don't know what it scores but I'm hoping it wasn't taken during 4pt only season.

[leadpillproductions]

It scores 148 and up here you count brows as a point for wt deer 4x4

[Dannybuoy]

I don't know what it scores but I'm hoping it wasn't taken during 4pt only season.

Its because you don't know what scores that you say that .... its a legal four point and a nice one at that .

[billjc33]

Wow 2 different posts in one thread not knowing what a 4 point whitey is. This forum is almost getting to be to much to read.

[Chopper]

145 gross class buck

[tracker]

139 3/8 gross :mrgreen:

[Blainer]

I noob it was something simple like this.

Thank you.Unless you an American
Then it's an 8 point
Everything is Bigger in America

I had him at 142", but see you posted he was 148"
Nice buck!

[BearStump]

With Whitetails, you count the brow tine as a point. With a Mulie you do not
right you are. but try to explain that one to an Islander. lol. its a delicate subject to the island folk that count everything..
That whitie is a cranker. me like!

[hare_assassin]

Wow 2 different posts in one thread not knowing what a 4 point whitey is. This forum is almost getting to be to much to read.

Why? Because there are new members who are learning from the experienced ones?

Shame on us.

[Sofa King]

I don't know what it scores but I'm hoping it wasn't taken during 4pt only season.

is there a 4 point only whitetail season?
where I hunt it's any whitetail always, and muley changes between any buck and 4 point only.
and it wouldn't matter anyway that's a 4 point whitey.

[Sofa King]

score, shmore.
who cares, that's an A+ buck.

[Mikey Rafiki]

is there a 4 point only whitetail season?
where I hunt it's any whitetail always, and muley changes between any buck and 4 point only.
and it wouldn't matter anyway that's a 4 point whitey.

I've never heard of a 4 pt whitey season, but I sure as hell don't pretend to know everything. It's a 4 point whitey as per the B&C definition I posted on pg 3. Great buck either way.

Big brows get me going, for bucks and the ladies...

[Dannybuoy]

score, shmore.
who cares, that's an A+ buck.

A lot of people care about score ... and to some net is important as well .. if I am after a nice mulie ... I am not going to shoot some mediocre 4 pointer ....

[pronghorn]

160-165 ish as he has some great length and the brows are awsome

[f350ps]

Wow, that's a character "Whitey"! Good job, congrats! K

[hunter1993ap]

144 popped into my head when I first saw it.

[Rich_D]

oops....dunno why I was thinking Mule deer.

4pt it is.

Either way, it's still a great looking buck.

[Wade]

Who cares what he scores, you can tell he's a nice buck just by looking at him

[hunter1947]

My guess is 141.5/8 net..

[Blainer]

score, shmore.
who cares, that's an A+ buck.The title of the threat is: "Try your hand and score this buck."
That's why! Buncha hunters having fun with a thread

[Dannybuoy]

Some good guessing . I actually thought it was going to break 150 but gross 148 5/8

Good score for a 4 point , he looked heavy but a bit narrow and short on the main beams eh ? That's why 150 is the number to get in the BC book .. its not that easy! I would have thought he was over 150 as well especially in the field .

[rifleman]

A real quick look (6 seconds) . I'll take a shot in the dark & guess 152"

[rifleman]

Did you get this one on video? Do you have a link?

[coach]

What's the over/under on the number of people that will continue to guess the score after the OP posted the 148 number? I say 18 by the end of the day..:-D

Congrats on a great buck, LPP!

[Dannybuoy]

What's the over/under on the number of people that will continue to guess the score after the OP posted the 148 number? I say 18 by the end of the day..:-D

Congrats on a great buck, LPP!
Odds are in your favour ... @9 (...@9) already .......

[leadpillproductions]

No video walked out of house waked over to field and shot him . not much of a hunt.

[Muliechaser]

Wow 2 different posts in one thread not knowing what a 4 point whitey is. This forum is almost getting to be to much to read.

Yeah it blows me away! . Some People cant read the regs properly . It is up to you to know the rules before hunting its all there in the regulations. If u have to ask u shouldnt be hunting period... Especially animal ID . YOU LEARN IT IN THE CORE. This may make me look like an asshole but seriously read that book over and over its all there.

I wonder how many pass up 3 point whiteys :-?

Or shoot 3 point muleys with brows. Makes me sick to even think about it. Sorry to highjack but shit. And to the OP. Id guess 145 when all is said and done. Nice buck!!!,

Mc

[Muliechaser]

Ooops. Didnt see you posted tge score. Have a hard time passin him up

[Brambles]

Just looking at I'd say 145 ish..... But you had me at big brows....

[300H&H]

I'm confused. I see a 3x3 with big brow tines.

Can someone explain why brow tines count in some cases and not in others?

Brow tines/eye guards always count.
On a scoring sheet they are the G1 measurements.

[300H&H]

is there a 4 point only whitetail season?
where I hunt it's any whitetail always, and muley changes between any buck and 4 point only.
and it wouldn't matter anyway that's a 4 point whitey.

There used to be here in Reg8. But that was years ago.
A buck had to have 4 points ABOVE the brow tine.
I had to pass on 2 super bucks because of that restriction.

[Muliechaser]

Brow tines/eye guards always count.
On a scoring sheet they are the G1 measurements.

You might want to rephrase that , might confuse some into beleiving. That for aboth species :mrgreen:

[300H&H]

With Whitetails, you count the brow tine as a point. With a Mulie you do not

Yes you do !
http://www.boone-crockett.org/bgRecords/images/scoring_typmuledeer1.gif (http://www.google.ca/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&docid=yOPqIKI1OQW48M&tbnid=6sUyQmuAt_YF8M:&ved=0CAUQjRw&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.boone-crockett.org%2FbgRecords%2Fbc_scoring_typmuledeer. asp%3Farea%3DbgRecords%26type%3DTypical%2BMule%2BD eer&ei=hYKXUpOOBdTnoATKyIHABQ&bvm=bv.57155469,d.cGU&psig=AFQjCNGk0JHUt1BVx7F1M60QAOEBsO7zkQ&ust=1385747392549159)

[coach]

You might want to rephrase that , might confuse some into beleiving. That for aboth species :mrgreen:

There's a difference between B&C scoring (where you do count brows) and antler point restrictions where you don't count brows (on mule deer).

Confused yet?

[coach]

Odds are in your favour ... @9 (...@9) already .......

I guess that makes it 11 now..

[hare_assassin]

There's a difference between B&C scoring (where you do count brows) and antler point restrictions where you don't count brows (on mule deer).

Confused yet?

No. It's very clear now, actually.

WT = always count the brow, whether for scoring or otherwise

MD = for legal tine restrictions, don't count the brow, but for scoring, count it.

Thank you to any who have directly or inadvertently educated me on this without feeling the need to be a c*nt about it.

[ridge runner]

148 5/8 - take a chance..........

[yama49]

But you are wrong. From the B&C website:

To be counted a point, the projection must be at least one inch long, with the length exceeding width at one inch or more of length. All points measured from tip of point to nearest edge of beam as illustrated in Figure A. Beam tip is counted as a point, but not measured as a point.

http://www.boone-crockett.org/bgRecords/bc_scoring_typwhitetail.asp?area=bgRecords&type=Typical+Whitetail+Deer

Yes you r correct, i worded it wrong.. I meant for scoring the buck which this thread is about..

[Mikey Rafiki]

Yes you r correct, i worded it wrong.. I meant for scoring the buck which this thread is about..

I hear ya.

At least we can all agree that big brows are awesome!

And I'm gonna guess again, 149 - 3/8







(just to mess with coach)