I appreciate the info guys, definitely some food for thought.
I appreciate the info guys, definitely some food for thought.
I was almost killed when climbing in Evans Creek Canyon while solo trekking across the Valhallas in 1975, this was while carrying my Fjallraven Expedition Frame Pack and that was then THE finest pack available of it's type. That was the LAST time I used an external frame pack in really steep country such as the West Kootenays, I prefer to come home alive.
I have owned and used packs of various types made by the best American, Canadian and European makers, made my living fitting them and have over 50 years of carrying packs all over BC and some of Alberta. NO pack I have ever seen is ideal for every situation and some compromise is always part of the equation.
I am very well aware that the Barney's is a much more solidly built rig than the frames it was derived from, I was just talking to Bob of Barney's a week or two before Christmas. But, the basic design issues are the same and the MR NICE and, especially, my almost 8500 cu. in. BDSB internal from MR ride closer to your spine and are thus more stable in really difficult climbing situations.
As I posted, the best idea is to have both and use them as you find they work best in your hunting; I would buy a Barney's tomorrow, but, at my age, what I now have will work for my remaining years of hunting and other mountain activities. If, I were to buy another pack, it would be an Inex Expedition "full Dyneema" pack custom built to my specs by Dan Mchale in Seattle, but, given the cost, it would be a foolish extravagance at this time of life.
If, anyone has a Barney's and would like to let me check it out and even do some gear trading and I have gobs of top stuff, let me know by PM, this is one pack I would really like to use as so many knowledgeable guys here and on other worthwhile forums are so happy with theirs.
Devilbear .... for what its worth, I had one of those old camptrails pack years ago that "swung" with weight if you were not careful. Needless to say, I had a fall on a sheep hunt that after I extricated myself from the bent pack, broken pins and all, that I was just happy I had nothing broken. It was that incident that caused me to start packing ski poles and the eventual transition to the hiking poles when they came on the market.
The Barney is definatly way more solid and does have adjustable should straps as well but as with any heavy load with any pack, get on the wrong side of momentum or a miss-step and you'll fall.
Very true... We've been in situations, with loaded packs where the country is so steep, you are climbing on your hands and knees as you lunge forward to the next foothold the pack is hitting the rocks above you before you can get a good hand hold, you've got your hiking poles in one hand, trying to climb with the other... Those ones make my heart beat 50 times really fast as you scramble to get hold, or then the shale gives, the rock moves etc... Danger Bay!but as with any heavy load with any pack, get on the wrong side of momentum or a miss-step and you'll fall.
Carl
Don't Go Ninja'n Nobody, Don't Need Ninja'n!
Ok, here is a MR6500. It has a large main compartment over a smaller compartment in which I put my sleeping bag, Exped Synmat 7 and some other stuff too. The outside of the pack has two long pockets, one gets my spotter and the other my tripod and the tent poles, plus raingear and other stuff. The main compartment is large, no need for load cels (they were designed for the Crewcab anyways), I use silnylon bags to keep my clothes, food, and stuff organized. As a bonus they can be used to transport and store water.
It's tough to take a decent picture of the inside of the pack but I hope you get the idea.
This one is of the pack loosely loaded (still lots of room to stuff gear into it). That is a 5 gallon bucket beside it and my Remington 700 Titanium .300WSM (24" barrel) to give you an idea of scale:
Side view:
The harness side:
I am getting long pockets to attach to each side of the pack for added storage and versatility in accessing stuff I use all the time.
Hope this helps!
Last edited by troutseeker; 01-05-2011 at 12:51 AM.
TS- You must be expecting to see lots of game taking a big bucket of bullets like that. I try to limit myself to one full ice cream pail.
SSS
https://oceola.ca/
http://bcwf.net/index.php
http://www.wildsheepsociety.net/
I Give my Heart to my Family....
My Mind to my Work.......
But My Soul Belongs to the Mountains.....